Our reviews
Reviews from Grubhub
Kiana
Top Reviewer
The most iconic mac and cheese in Chelsea. Delivered piping hot!
Vanwah
1 review
Good ambiance , friendly staff, great tasting food
archie
Top Reviewer
Dear jeezus, the carrot cake is addictive!
Rosemary
Top Reviewer
Excellent food! Swift delivery too.
Maria
4 reviews
Excellent food, quick delivery
Reviews from Seamless.com
Karen
1 review
This place puts out consistently delicious comfort food, period. The mac and cheese dishes are decadent (the Gouda & Bacon is my favorite), and the spinach salad is fresh and balanced with lots of great flavors going on. They also deliver quickly and the food is hot upon arrival (always appreciated and doesn't always happen with takeout in general). Highly recommend!
Abbey
Top Reviewer
Food arrived hot, drinks arrived cold. Everything packed really well. Food was delicious. Delivery came before the quoted window. Delivery guy was really pleasant. A little pricey, but you are getting quality food. They don't mess around. You won't regret ordering from here.
Denise
Top Reviewer
Best burger and truffle fries! I was informed the delivery would be later than I was originally told but my food arrived on time! AND the food was packed in paper, not plastic, cartons! That warrants an extra 5 Stars!!
Anne
Top Reviewer
My order was wrong and the correct one never arrived BUT the folks at Cafeteria were super nice, professional, and apologetic, and gave me a refund. Great customer service. Thank you! One of my go-to restaurants for more than one reason.
Ricky
2 reviews
I know the restaurant well. It's great for what it is. Very popular Chelsea eatery.
I have been ordering from them regularly this past month because they're two blocks away and I'm confined to my hotel room after major surgery.
I have been ordering from them regularly this past month because they're two blocks away and I'm confined to my hotel room after major surgery.
About us
American, Breakfast, Hamburgers, Healthy, Lunch, Salads
Today
Delivery: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Takeout: 10:00 AM - 4:00 PM
Start by serving exceptional American comfort food with a contemporary twist. Create an electric, modern, yet intimate ambiance where people can meet and gather in the heart of Chelsea. And the best part? Keep It All running 24 hours a day. In the 15 years since Cafeteria doors first opened, this delicious brainchild of three New York City entrepreneurs has become a full-fledged phenomenon. From weekend brunches to late night noshing with inimitable style, Cafeteria is your only destination.